Ordering and factories

How many faulty pieces can a clothing factory send you?

· 4 min read

Unless you agreed in writing before production how many pieces may be faulty and which defects count as a fail, the answer is as many as the factory can argue are acceptable.

On this page
  1. How many faulty pieces is a factory allowed to send?
  2. Is it normal for a production order to include some faulty pieces?
  3. Which defects should fail a piece, and which can be repaired?
  4. What should a written quality agreement include?
  5. How do you check a delivery against the agreement?
  6. What does it mean if a factory will not agree a defect list?

How many faulty pieces is a factory allowed to send?

As many as you agreed to accept, and if you never wrote a number down, as many as the factory can argue are fine. There is no figure that applies by default. The limit is whatever was put in writing before production, and without it a delivery becomes a negotiation.

That is why most arguments about faulty pieces are not really about the pieces. They are about a list that nobody wrote down before the job started. Once the goods have arrived, both sides are describing the same garments in different words, and neither has anything to point to.

Is it normal for a production order to include some faulty pieces?

Yes. A production run will usually contain a few pieces with something wrong: a stitch that wanders, a mark on the fabric, a label sewn in crooked. That is normal in sewn production, even in a well-run factory.

So the useful question is not whether there will be any. It is how many you agreed to accept, and what counts as faulty in the first place. Both answers have to exist before production, because after delivery they are no longer neutral.

Which defects should fail a piece, and which can be repaired?

Agree two lists: faults that fail a piece outright, and faults that are fixed rather than rejected. The line between them is a judgement about how serious the fault is and how easily it can be corrected, and it is far easier to draw before anyone has a stake in the answer.

faultusual treatment
Broken seamFails
HoleFails
Measurement outside toleranceFails
Wrong colourFails
Loose threadUsually repaired, not rejected
A mark that comes outUsually repaired, not rejected
Stitch that wanders, crooked labelDecide in advance, and write down which side it falls on

A broken seam fails because the garment does not do its job. A loose thread usually does not, because it is a simple fix, and rejecting a piece for it makes little sense when it affects only a few units in a large batch.

The middle cases are where disputes start. A stitch line that drifts slightly on an inside seam and one that wanders across a visible topstitch are not the same fault. If a detail matters to how the garment looks, name it on the list.

What should a written quality agreement include?

Two things at minimum: how many pieces in the order can be faulty, and a list of what fails. Beyond that, a few additions make the agreement usable when the goods arrive.

  • The acceptable number. How many faulty pieces the order may contain before the delivery is not accepted as it stands.
  • The fail list. Faults that reject a piece, such as broken seams, holes, measurements outside tolerance and wrong colour.
  • The repair list. Faults that are corrected rather than rejected, such as loose threads and marks that come out.
  • The reference. The approved sample, and the measurement tolerances in the tech pack, so "outside tolerance" has a number behind it.
  • The colour standard. What counts as the wrong colour, measured against the approved lab dip rather than described by eye.
  • What happens next. Whether faulty pieces are replaced, repaired or credited, and who pays to send them back.

All of this belongs in writing before production starts, attached to the order rather than buried in an email thread.

How do you check a delivery against the agreement?

Check it against the list, not against how you feel about it. Sort what you find into the categories you agreed: pieces that pass, faults to be repaired, and pieces that fail. Then compare the count of failures with the number you agreed to accept.

Measure against the tolerances in the tech pack rather than against a single garment you like. Look at colour in daylight against the approved standard. Note each fault with a photograph and the piece it came from, so the conversation that follows is about specific garments rather than an impression of the batch.

Done this way, most deliveries do not turn into an argument at all. Either the order is inside the agreement or it is not, and both sides can see which.

What does it mean if a factory will not agree a defect list?

It tells you how the conversation will go after delivery. A factory that will not commit to a number and a fail list before production is keeping its options open for later, when the goods are made and your position is weaker.

That is not proof of bad intent, but it is information. A supplier confident in its work usually has no difficulty saying in advance what it considers a fail. If the answer is vague now, expect it to be vague when you are holding a faulty piece.

What to agree before production starts

Put the acceptable number and the fail list into the order, alongside the approved sample and the tech pack tolerances. Check deliveries against that document, not against memory. A factory's own final check is useful, but it is the factory marking its own work, so plan for an inspection on your side as well. Splot manages quality control as part of running production, and the same principle applies: inspect against what was agreed.

For the checks to run on fabric before it is cut, read four checks to run on fabric before you accept it. For what to ask before the balance is paid, see what to ask before the deposit, and before the bulk ships.

Keep reading

Ask us about yours.

Tell us what you want made and we will tell you what it takes before you commit to anything. The quote is free.