What pigment dye is, and why pigment-dyed shirts keep fading
· 4 min read
Pigment dye is coloured particles held on the outside of the yarn by a glue called a binder, so it fades where the garment rubs and can transfer colour, which is why you ask for the dry and wet crocking grades, each scored from one to five.
On this page
What is pigment dye?
Pigment dye is not a dye in the strict sense. It is coloured particles that will not hold onto cotton by themselves, so they are mixed with a glue called a binder and baked onto the fabric.
A dye dissolves in water and soaks into the cotton fibre itself. A pigment does not dissolve. It stays as particles, and without the binder it would simply wash out. The binder is what holds the colour in place, and the heat is what sets the binder.
The practical result is that the colour sits on the outside of the yarn rather than through it. Everything a brand likes about pigment dye, and everything that causes trouble with it, follows from that one fact.
How is pigment dye different from a normal cotton dye?
The difference is where the colour lives. A dye is inside the fibre; a pigment is on the surface, held there by binder.
| Dye | Pigment | |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Dissolves in water | Particles that do not dissolve |
| How it attaches | Soaks into the fibre | Glued on with a binder, baked on |
| Where the colour sits | In the fibre | On the outside of the yarn |
| Look | Even, solid colour | Faded, chalky, already worn |
| How it ages | Fades more gradually | Keeps fading, first where it rubs |
| The test to ask for | Colour against the approved standard | Rub-off, dry and wet |
Neither is better in general. A dyed cotton tee is the choice when the colour has to stay put. A pigment-dyed one is the choice when the worn, uneven surface is the point of the product. The mistake is ordering the second and expecting it to behave like the first.
The binder also has a side effect worth checking on the sample: it is a layer on the fabric, and it can change how the fabric feels in the hand. Judge the handle of a pigment-dyed sample, not of the undyed base cloth.
Why does a pigment-dyed shirt keep fading?
Because the colour is on the surface, and the surface is what gets worn. Washing and wearing remove a little binder and a little pigment each time.
That is also where the look comes from. The chalky, softened colour that makes a new pigment-dyed shirt look as though it has been owned for years is the same mechanism at an early stage. The fading does not stop at the shade the customer bought; it carries on.
For a brand this matters in two places. The product description and the care label should not promise a colour that stays as it is. And whoever answers customer emails should expect questions from people who did not know the fade was part of the product. Saying it plainly on the product page, as a feature, is easier than explaining it in a reply to a complaint.
Where on the garment does pigment dye fade first?
Where the shirt rubs: the collar, the seams and the cuffs. These are the points that take the most friction, against skin, against other clothes and against the drum of a washing machine.
Seams go early because the fabric is folded and raised there, so it meets the friction before the flat panels do. The collar rubs against the neck all day. Cuffs meet tables, bags and wrists.
This uneven fade is often exactly what people want from the finish, and on a fresh sample it can look very good. What you need to know is how quickly it happens. Wash a sample several times and lay it next to an unwashed one. If the collar and seams have gone pale long before the body, that is the shirt your customer will own a few months in.
What is crocking?
Crocking is colour rubbing off one material onto another. The crocking test rubs the fabric against a white test cloth and grades how much colour moves across, on a scale of one to five.
On that scale five means no visible transfer and one means heavy transfer. What rubs off the shirt rubs onto something else: a pale sofa, a car seat, the strap of a light-coloured bag, the shirt worn underneath. With pigment dye this is a real risk, because the colour is on the surface and some of it is only loosely held. A dark pigment colour that rubs off badly is the kind of fault that comes back as returns.
Why ask for both the dry and the wet grade?
Because the test is done twice, once on dry fabric and once on wet, and each condition gets its own grade. One number without saying which test it came from tells you half of what you need.
Dry rubbing is the shirt against a chair or a bag on an ordinary day. Wet rubbing is the shirt in the rain, or damp with sweat, against whatever it touches. Fabric that passes dry can still transfer colour wet, and the wet result is commonly the weaker of the two.
Ask for both grades for each colour, not one figure for the range. A pale pigment colour and a dark one from the same factory can grade differently, and it is usually the dark one that marks other things.
What to agree before ordering a pigment-dyed colour
Settle these with the factory while the sample is still on the table:
- The dry and the wet crocking grade for every colour in the order, in writing, and the lowest grade you will accept.
- A washed sample beside an unwashed one, so you can see how fast the collar, seams and cuffs fade.
- Care instructions that suit the finish. Washing inside out reduces the rubbing that strips the colour from the outside of the yarn.
- A line on the product page that tells the customer the colour will soften with wear, so the fade arrives as expected rather than as a fault.
For a quick version of the rub test you can run yourself on incoming fabric, see four checks to run on fabric before you accept it. To put the grades into the specification from the start, start with a free tech pack.