How much returns cost an online clothing brand
By Splot · · 5 min read
In this worked example one returned €75 hoodie costs the brand about €12.60, or €18.60 if it pays for the return label, so at a 20% return rate every sale needs an allowance of €2.52 to €3.72 before it shows a profit.
On this page
What does one return cost a clothing brand?
About €12.60 in this example, and €18.60 if the brand pays for the return label. The price is refunded, so the cost of a return is everything the brand spent on the sale that it does not get back, plus the pieces that come back unsellable.
The example is a hoodie sold online for €75 net of VAT, with a landed cost of €40 a piece. Every figure in the table is an assumption, set out so you can replace it with your own.
| per return | customer pays the return label | brand pays the return label |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery to the customer, refunded or paid by you | €5.00 | €5.00 |
| Return label | €0.00 | €6.00 |
| Handling: unpack, check, steam, re-bag | €2.00 | €2.00 |
| Payment fee you do not get back | €1.60 | €1.60 |
| Write-off: 1 in 10 returns unsellable, at €40 | €4.00 | €4.00 |
| Cost of one return | €12.60 | €18.60 |
Whether a payment provider keeps its fee on a refund depends on the provider, so check yours before keeping that line. If the order came from an advertisement, the money spent to win it is gone too, which adds whatever one order costs you to find.
Why does the brand pay for delivery on a returned order?
Because EU consumer law says so. A consumer who buys online has 14 days to withdraw from the contract without giving a reason. The trader then has to refund all payments received, including the cost of standard delivery, within 14 days of being told. The consumer pays only the direct cost of sending the goods back, unless the trader agreed to pay it or did not tell the consumer they would have to.
So even when the customer paid €5 for delivery, that €5 goes back to them, and the brand has paid the courier anyway. The trader may hold the refund until the goods are back, or until the customer shows proof of sending them, whichever comes first.
These rules come from the EU Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU), articles 9, 13 and 14. Poland implements them in the Consumer Rights Act of 30 May 2014, articles 27, 32 and 34. They apply to sales to consumers; a shop buying wholesale is a business and has no such right.
How much should each sale carry for returns?
The return rate multiplied by the cost of one return. A brand without its own data yet can model three rates and see which one the plan survives.
| return rate | allowance per sale, customer pays label | allowance per sale, brand pays label |
|---|---|---|
| 10% | €1.26 | €1.86 |
| 20% | €2.52 | €3.72 |
| 30% | €3.78 | €5.58 |
On a €75 hoodie, €5.58 is 7.4% of the price. It belongs on the per-sale line of the unit economics, next to the card fee and packing, as in the financial model guide. A plan that leaves €20 a sale before returns and loses €5.58 to them has given up more than a quarter of its profit.
There is also a cash cost. A returned piece is out of stock for the weeks it spends travelling back and being checked, and the refund leaves the account within 14 days. On a small run of 50, ten pieces in transit is a fifth of the stock.
Should a small brand offer free returns?
It depends on which part of the policy you make generous. A meta-analysis of 21 studies found that, overall, a more lenient return policy increases purchases more than it increases returns (Janakiraman, Syrdal and Freling, 2016). The parts did not all work the same way:
- Money and effort leniency, such as free returns or an easy process, increased purchases.
- Scope leniency, accepting more kinds of items or conditions, increased returns.
- Time and exchange leniency, a longer window or an exchange option, reduced returns.
Work on retail customers points the same way: product returns are inevitable, and in the authors' words "by no means evil" (Petersen and Kumar, 2009). In a six-month field experiment with 26,000 customers of an online retailer, accounting for the lower risk a buyer feels when returning is possible, as well as for the cost of returns, raised both short-term and long-term profit (Petersen and Kumar, 2015).
For a small brand this points to a shape of policy: an exchange option and a clear window, a defined scope, and a return label only if the margin carries the €6 in the table.
What lowers the return rate of a clothing brand?
Fit, which production controls, and a buyer who can judge it before ordering. In randomized field experiments at an online retailer, showing customers virtual fit information raised conversion and order value and cut the fulfilment costs of returns, including customers ordering several sizes of the same item (Gallino and Moreno, 2018). A study of fashion e-commerce identified ten categories of reason behind online returns, and when in the process the decision to return was made (Saarijärvi, Sutinen and Harris, 2017).
Much of that is settled in production, before the product page exists:
- A size chart of garment measurements, with a tolerance for each, published on the product page. How to make a size chart for a clothing brand shows the format a factory can produce from.
- Measurements taken after washing, so the chart still holds after the first wash. How to specify shrinkage so garments fit after washing covers the 3% limit to write down.
- An approved sample as the production standard, so the 50th hoodie fits like the one in the photos. Splot's terms make the approved sample the standard production is made to.
How do you budget returns for your own brand?
- List what one return costs you, line by line, as in the first table.
- Pick a return rate. Use your own once you have a few months of orders; until then, model 10%, 20% and 30%.
- Multiply, and put the result on every sale as a cost.
- Check the plan at the highest rate. If one sale leaves nothing, change the price, the policy or the product before launch.
- Track the reasons customers give for each return, and fix the size chart or the spec when one reason repeats.
Short answers
Do I have to accept returns on clothes sold online?
For sales to consumers in the EU, yes, apart from the exceptions the directive lists in article 16: the buyer can withdraw within 14 days without giving a reason, and send the goods back within 14 days after that. For wholesale orders from shops, no such right applies.
Who pays the return shipping?
The customer, by default, as long as you told them that they would. You pay it if you offered to or did not tell them. Either way you refund the cost of the original standard delivery.
What return rate should I plan for?
Your own, once you have one. Before launch, run the budget at 10%, 20% and 30%, and make sure the business still works at the highest of the three.
Does a better size chart really reduce returns?
The field experiments by Gallino and Moreno (2018) tested a virtual fitting tool, not a size chart. Showing customers how an item would fit cut return costs and the ordering of several sizes of one item. A size chart with garment measurements gives the customer some of the same information, so it is the first thing to fix, but no study cited here measured its effect on its own.
Sources
- Janakiraman, N., Syrdal, H. A. and Freling, R. (2016). The effect of return policy leniency on consumer purchase and return decisions: a meta-analytic review. Journal of Retailing, 92(2), 226-235. doi:10.1016/j.jretai.2015.11.002
- Petersen, J. A. and Kumar, V. (2009). Are product returns a necessary evil? Antecedents and consequences. Journal of Marketing, 73(3), 35-51. doi:10.1509/jmkg.73.3.35
- Petersen, J. A. and Kumar, V. (2015). Perceived risk, product returns, and optimal resource allocation: evidence from a field experiment. Journal of Marketing Research, 52(2), 268-285. doi:10.1509/jmr.14.0174
- Gallino, S. and Moreno, A. (2018). The value of fit information in online retail: evidence from a randomized field experiment. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 20(4), 767-787. doi:10.1287/msom.2017.0686
- Saarijärvi, H., Sutinen, U.-M. and Harris, L. C. (2017). Uncovering consumers' returning behaviour: a study of fashion e-commerce. The International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research, 27(3), 284-299. doi:10.1080/09593969.2017.1314863
- Directive 2011/83/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on consumer rights, articles 9, 13 and 14. EUR-Lex
- Ustawa z dnia 30 maja 2014 r. o prawach konsumenta (Dz.U. 2014 poz. 827), articles 27, 32 and 34. ISAP