Ring-spun or open-end: why new t-shirts go rough and old ones stay soft
· 4 min read
Vintage t-shirts were made from ring-spun yarn, which keeps its long fibres and softens in the wash, while most new t-shirts use open-end rotor yarn, a method that reached its first mill in 1967 and carries more short fibres that work loose and leave the shirt rough.
On this page
Why does a vintage t-shirt feel softer than a new one?
Because it was most likely spun differently. The cotton has not changed; the machine that turns it into yarn has.
An older tee was spun on a ring frame, which works slowly and leaves the fibres long and parallel. Most t-shirts sold today are made from rotor yarn, also called open-end yarn, which is faster and cheaper to make and carries far more short fibres. Those short fibres are what make a new shirt feel rough after a few weeks of washing, and their absence is what lets an old one get softer.
There is a selection effect as well. A shirt that is still in a drawer after decades of washing is there because it stayed pleasant to wear. A vintage t-shirt is soft enough to keep, which is why it was kept.
What is the difference between ring-spun and open-end yarn?
Ring spinning draws the fibres out long and lays them parallel before twisting them into yarn. Open-end spinning throws the fibres at the wall of a rotor turning at up to 150,000 rpm and twists them there.
| Ring spun | Open-end (rotor) | |
|---|---|---|
| How the yarn is formed | Fibres drawn out and laid parallel, then twisted | Fibres thrown at a rotor wall and twisted there |
| Speed | Slow | Much faster |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Short fibres in the yarn | Fewer | Far more |
| After repeated washing | Breaks in and softens | Sheds fibres and goes rough |
| Where you find it | Vintage tees, better jersey today | Most of the cotton jersey on the high street |
The table is not a case against rotor yarn. It made cotton jersey faster and cheaper to produce, and there are products where that is the right trade. The point is that the two yarns behave differently over the life of a garment, and a brand should choose between them knowingly.
When did open-end spinning arrive?
In the 1960s. Rotor spinning was invented in Czechoslovakia in 1963, the first mill-scale machine ran in 1966, and the world's first rotor spinning mill opened at Usti nad Orlici in August 1967.
Before that, the ring frame was the standard way to spin cotton yarn for jersey. The rotor replaced it across much of the industry because it was faster and cheaper than anything before it. It now accounts for most of the cotton jersey on the high street.
That timing is why the vintage comparison works so neatly. A t-shirt made before rotor yarn became common was ring spun almost by default. A t-shirt made today is ring spun only if somebody chose to pay for it.
Why does open-end cotton go rough after washing?
Because rotor yarn carries far more short fibres, and a short fibre finishes with both of its ends at the surface of the yarn. Washing works those ends free, a few at a time.
That roughness a month in is the yarn shedding itself, not the fabric wearing out. The shirt has not thinned or torn. Its surface has simply filled with loose fibre ends that you feel against the skin.
Ring-spun yarn holds on to its fibres. With fewer ends at the surface, there is less for the wash to pull loose, so the shirt breaks in rather than going rough. It softens as it is washed instead of hardening.
Is combed cotton the same as ring-spun?
No. They are two separate claims about two separate stages. Carding and combing describe how the fibre is prepared before spinning. Ring and open-end describe how it is spun.
Combing removes shorter fibres and aligns the rest, so it also works against roughness, but it says nothing about which machine made the yarn. A fabric can be combed and open-end, carded and ring spun, or any other pairing. The better jersey is both combed and ring spun.
A brand that has paid for both will usually say so on the label or in the product description. If a supplier's fabric description names one and not the other, ask about the missing one directly.
Does a heavier t-shirt mean better quality?
No. Weight tells you how much cotton is in the fabric, not how well it was spun. A heavy shirt made from open-end yarn will still go rough.
Grams per square metre is a useful number, and worth checking on delivery, but it measures a quantity. Two jerseys at the same gsm can feel and age quite differently depending on the yarn. A heavyweight tee is a style choice about drape and structure. It is not a substitute for specifying the yarn.
How to specify the yarn on your t-shirt
When you brief a jersey, describe the yarn as well as the weight:
- Spinning: ring spun or open-end, stated in the fabric specification.
- Fibre preparation: combed or carded.
- Weight: the gsm you want, and a check that the delivered fabric matches it.
- A wash test on the sample: wash it several times and compare the surface with an unwashed piece. A surface that has gone rough after a few washes points to short fibres in the yarn.
Use the shirt you already own as a reference. If something in your drawer has survived years of washing and got softer doing it, that is what long fibres, spun slowly, feel like, and it is a fair thing to hand a mill as a target. Browse the fabric library, and see four checks to run on fabric before you accept it for how to confirm the weight you paid for.